Dilemma
Pattern
If A then X; if B then X — forked argument, same conclusion
Definition
A form of argument that presents two or more alternatives, each of which leads to the same conclusion or an equally undesirable outcome.
Examples
Example 1
If you tell the truth, they'll punish you. If you lie, your conscience will punish you. Either way, you suffer.
A classic dilemma presenting two paths, both leading to an undesirable outcome
Example 2
Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
Proverbial expression
The most compact expression of dilemma in English — two alternatives, both condemned
Example 3
If we raise interest rates, we cause a recession. If we don't, we let inflation destroy savings. Which poison do we choose?
An economic dilemma that frames policy choices as equally damaging options
AI Detection Note
AI can produce dilemmas but tends to make them too clean — presenting only two alternatives when real situations have more, and making the convergence on a single conclusion feel manufactured rather than genuinely inescapable.
See how your writing uses this figure
Analyze Your Text